Feeders
Best no-waste and rat-resistant chicken feeders
Wasted feed and rats are related problems, not the same problem. A port stops hens from billing pellets onto the ground. A treadle is what you buy when something else is eating at night.
A hanging pan under a dry roof is a fine feeder until you watch a hen rake half of it onto the litter, and then watch who shows up after dark. The fixes that are actually sold fall into two piles. Port and trough designs make it harder for a beak to fling feed. Treadle designs close the feed when no bird is standing on the step, which is the feature aimed at rats, mice, and sparrows.
Nothing in this shortlist is a rat-proof coop. The feeder can close. Spilled pellets, eggs, and an open bag in the shed still feed rodents. Grandpa's says the lid keeps rats and sparrows out. A city keeper on Reddit said the rats where they live were not impressed. Both of those can be true.
We checked prices and spec pages on November 18, 2026. The training notes and the complaints come from the makers' own pages and from r/BackYardChickens. The people behind The Coop Shortlist keep backyard chickens. We have not run a scale on these treadles or a camera on a rat. If a product's rat claim was only a sentence on a review blog, it is not here.
| Product | Job | Holds | Birds at once | Price checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grandpa's Feeder, standard and large | Treadle, closed when empty | 20 lb or 40 lb | 3–5 | $187.95 / $245.95 |
| RentACoop 25 lb metal treadle feeder | Treadle, closed when empty | 25 lb | Not published | $179.95 |
| Roamwild PestOff chicken feeder | Spring ports | 8 lb | 2 | $49.99 |
| RentACoop 25 lb 4-port feeder | Less waste, covers you close | 25 lb | 4 ports | $69.95 |
The first two are treadles, for rodents and wild birds. The third is a small spring-port feeder with a bold claim and a contradicting review on the maker's own UK site. The fourth cuts waste and only keeps rats out if you close the covers yourself. That order is the decision, not a score.
Shortlist 01
Grandpa's Feeder, standard and large
Best for: A flock with rats, mice, or wild birds at the feeder, and an owner who will spend about two weeks training the hens.
$187.95 standard, $245.95 large. Grandpa's listed the standard at $187.95 and the large at $245.95. The large page still showed a backorder notice dated June 23, 2026, which is before the day we checked, so confirm the large is actually shipping. Price as of Nov 18, 2026; may change. See it at Grandpa's Feeders.
Grandpa's is the treadle people mean when they say treadle. You step on a plate, a lid over the trough opens, you step off, it closes. The standard page says the cantilevered lid is there to stop sparrows, rats, mice, and other pests, that the lid keeps rain off the feed, and that it holds about 20 pounds, which they figure as six hens for about ten days. The large holds about 40 pounds, figured as twelve hens for ten days. Both are galvanized, with an aluminum tread plate, and both pages offer a 24-month money-back guarantee. Dry feed only.
The part the product page is honest about, and that Reddit argues over, is training. The feeder ships with two bolts that limit how far the lid moves. Grandpa's says one week on each of two settings. On r/BackYardChickens, keepers describe everything from a hen standing on the plate on day three to a full month before the flock is calm. The ugly week is the second one, when the lid moves and makes a noise. Birds startle, they scare each other, and if the feeder is their only food they can go off eating while you wait. One keeper in that situation put the feeder away and went back to a backup. Have another way to feed them that week. Do not leave the lid propped open overnight if rats are why you bought it. An open lid is an invitation.
Chicks are a hard no from the maker: a small bird can be caught when a larger one steps off and the lid drops. The large-feeder page has a customer review that says the same thing in plainer language, and Grandpa's reply says the feeder is not for young birds, that there is a minimum weight, and that an anti-flick grill is there so birds do not kick feed out of the trough. Read that exchange before you decide the lid is harmless. Light bantams can be made to work, the maker says, by adding a little weight to the tread plate. Do not guess. Their instructions are the adjustment, not a brick you found in the yard, though that is exactly what some owners end up doing.
Rats are the other hard sentence. A keeper who said they live in a city wrote that a Grandpa's was not rat-proof against the rats they have, and that they moved to a RentACoop treadle. Other keepers in the same conversations say they stopped seeing rodents in the feeder and that feed stopped getting wet outdoors. Grandpa's language is "prevents access." It is not a warranty against every rat. Spilled feed still counts. So does the week of training.
The large was listed at $245.95. Its page still displayed a backorder note with a delivery date of June 23, 2026. We checked on November 18, 2026, so that sentence is stale or the large is still a problem. Ask before you plan a trip around it. The standard, at $187.95, is the one to buy unless you actually have a dozen birds and hate refilling. Three or four birds can eat at the standard at once. A big flock at morning turnout will queue. One reviewer said they put out a regular feeder for the first ten minutes and then took it away. That is a reasonable patch, and it is also a way to spill feed on the ground again.
Pros
- A weight-activated lid. Grandpa's says it keeps out sparrows, rats, mice, and other pests. The feed is covered when no bird is on the step.
- The maker publishes a training plan: two bolts, two settings, about a week on each.
- Galvanized body and an aluminum tread plate. Standard holds about 20 lb. Large holds about 40 lb.
- Grandpa's offers a 24-month money-back guarantee on the product page, and says the feeder is for dry feed.
Cons
- Training is real. On Reddit, some flocks learn in days and some take about a month. The week the lid starts to move is when hens spook and may stop eating.
- The maker says not to use it with baby chicks, because a chick can be caught when a bigger bird steps off. A review on the large-feeder page describes a lid coming down on a bird. Grandpa's reply says birds should stand on the treadle, not in the trough, and points to an anti-flick grill.
- It is not a guarantee. One city keeper said their rats still beat a Grandpa's and switched to a RentACoop treadle.
- Only three or four hens eat at once on the standard, four or five on the large. The morning rush needs a plan. The large page's stock notice looked stale.
Who it is not for
Chicks, most bantams unless you add weight to the treadle the way the maker describes, or anyone who needs the rats solved tonight. While the lid is propped open for training, it is just a metal box of feed.
- Standard
- About 20 lb. 11.5 in high × 17 in wide × 20 in deep. About 15 lb empty.
- Large
- About 40 lb. 16 × 22 × 25 in. About 23 lb empty.
- At once
- Standard 3–4 birds. Large 4–5 birds.
- Maker's flock note
- Standard: about 6 hens for 10 days, or more if you refill. Large: about 12 hens for 10 days.
- Training
- Two stages, about one week each, with the included bolts.
- Not for
- Baby chicks. Light bantams need weight added to the treadle, per Grandpa's.
Sources: Grandpa's standard feeder; Grandpa's large feeder, including the stock note and reviews; r/BackYardChickens: experiences with Grandpa's; r/BackYardChickens: step-on feeders, including a city-rat comment; r/BackYardChickens: week two of training.
Shortlist 02
RentACoop 25 lb metal treadle feeder
Best for: The same rat-and-waste job as a Grandpa's, if you want the rain cover and anti-roost parts in the box and a price in the same range.
$179.95. RentACoop listed this 25 lb metal treadle feeder at $179.95. Price as of Nov 18, 2026; may change. See it at RentACoop.
RentACoop's metal treadle is the direct alternative to Grandpa's. The page says the step opens only while the birds eat, to keep rats, mice, squirrels, and wild birds out of the feed, and that the covered metal body keeps feed off the dirt. Capacity is 25 pounds. They figure about six adult hens for up to ten days. The box includes the treadle, two blinders, a rain cover, an anti-roost lid, and hardware. The price was $179.95, a few dollars under the Grandpa's standard.
What the page does not give you is a published "this much weight opens it" number, or the two-week bolt plan Grandpa's prints. You should still expect a training period. On the Grandpa's thread, one keeper said their birds had the RentACoop treadle figured out in about four hours, and another said they switched to RentACoop because city rats were beating a Grandpa's and that the RentACoop "has springs" to hold bigger rats out. We are not going to turn that into a spec. The product page we read talks about a treadle, not about a spring rating. Take the comment as a keeper's reason for switching, then read the current page yourself.
The rain cover and the anti-roost lid are the practical difference in the box. Grandpa's relies on its own lid to shed rain. RentACoop ships a separate rain cover and a lid meant to stop birds sitting on top. Birds on top of a treadle are how you get a surprise closing on whoever is eating, which is the injury mode Grandpa's customers argue about. An anti-roost lid is aimed at that. It is not a promise that no hen will ever stand on it.
Same limits as any treadle: not for chicks, a poor fit if you will not spend a week teaching, and useless against feed that is already on the ground. If your problem is hens billing pellets out of an open pan and you do not have rodents, the port feeder further down is the cheaper tool.
Pros
- RentACoop says the treadle opens only while birds eat, to block rats, mice, squirrels, and wild birds.
- 25 lb capacity. They say about six adult hens for up to 10 days, on pellets, crumble, or scratch.
- Galvanized body, stainless hardware, a rain cover, an anti-roost lid, and blinders are in the box.
- A bit less money than the Grandpa's standard, with a similar claimed capacity.
Cons
- You still have to train hens. A treadle that never gets learned is an expensive closed box.
- We did not find a published activation weight on the product page, which Grandpa's training notes are clearer about.
- One Reddit keeper preferred it to Grandpa's for large city rats. That is one comparison, not a lab result, and RentACoop's page does not publish a "stops large rats" spec.
- Metal treadles are loud when the lid moves. Nervous birds, especially roosters in other owners' stories about this style of feeder, take longer.
Who it is not for
Chicks, a flock that will not be trained, or anyone shopping only on a "rat proof" headline. It is a step-on lid. It is not a sealed vault.
- Capacity
- 25 lb
- Maker's flock note
- About 6 adult hens for up to 10 days
- Body
- Galvanized metal, stainless hardware
- Included
- Treadle, 2 blinders, rain cover, anti-roost lid, hardware
- Feed
- Pellets, crumble, or scratch, per RentACoop
- Price
- $179.95 on the RentACoop page
Sources: RentACoop 25 lb metal treadle feeder; r/BackYardChickens, where keepers compare it with Grandpa's.
Shortlist 03
Roamwild PestOff chicken feeder
Best for: A small flock, a lower budget, and a keeper who wants ports rather than a treadle and will believe the pest claim only halfway.
$49.99. Roamwild's US page listed it at $49.99, with free US shipping from Columbus, Ohio. Price as of Nov 18, 2026; may change. See it at Roamwild.
The PestOff feeder is Roamwild's chicken version of their spring-port bird feeders. Each port is supposed to stay open for the weight of a chicken and shut for anything lighter. The US page says there is nothing to calibrate and no training period, that it holds 8 pounds, that two hens can eat at once, and that it is weatherproof metal. The price was $49.99 with free US shipping. Their FAQ uses a quarter pound of feed a day per laying hen, which makes 8 pounds about five days for six hens, or a little over two weeks for two hens. Treat the quarter-pound figure as their planning number. A cold week and a heavy breed eat more.
The claim on that FAQ is "100% pest-proof by design." The reason this feeder is not higher on the page is a review on Roamwild's own UK listing. The reviewer wrote that they bought it because of rats, and that within a week rats were feeding by jumping to the ledge above the opening and eating from above. That is not a lab report. It is a customer review the maker's site is displaying, and it describes a way around a port that closes only when something hangs on the port itself. If your rats are climbers, a lid that covers the whole trough is the more obvious barrier. A port is a smaller door.
For two or three hens, no treadle training, and a price you can walk away from, it is a reasonable experiment. For a known rat problem and a flock that already wastes a bag a week, buy the treadle. You will spend more, and you will spend two weeks teaching, and you will still sweep up spills. You will not be betting the winter on a spring and a ledge.
Pros
- Two spring-loaded ports. Roamwild says they open under a chicken and stay shut for rats, pigeons, and crows, with nothing to calibrate.
- $49.99, against nearly $180 for a treadle. Eight pounds of capacity.
- Metal, and the US page calls it weatherproof. It comes apart for cleaning.
- No two-week training plan. That is the real convenience if the ports work as described.
Cons
- Eight pounds is small. Roamwild's own FAQ, using about a quarter pound of feed per hen per day, figures roughly five days for six hens.
- Only two birds can eat at once.
- A review published on Roamwild's UK product page says rats jumped to the ledge above the opening and ate from above within a week. The US page still says "100% pest-proof by design."
- We do not have a long public record of this feeder in hard rat pressure comparable to the treadle threads.
Who it is not for
A dozen hens, a serious rat problem you cannot afford to experiment on, or anyone who reads "100% pest-proof" and stops there. The maker's UK page hosts a review that says rats fed from the ledge above the port within a week.
- Capacity
- Up to 8 lb (4 liters)
- Size
- 15.7 × 8.3 × 8.3 in
- Ports
- 2, individually spring-loaded
- Material
- Metal, described as weatherproof by Roamwild
- Training
- None, according to the maker
- Price
- $49.99 on the US product page
Sources: Roamwild PestOff US product page; Roamwild UK page, including the rat review.
Shortlist 04
RentACoop 25 lb 4-port feeder
Best for: Hens that fling feed out of an open pan, a covered coop or run, and no serious rodent pressure. Or a keeper who will actually slide the port covers shut every night.
$69.95. RentACoop listed the 25 lb four-port feeder with stand at $69.95. Price as of Nov 18, 2026; may change. See it at RentACoop.
This is the waste feeder, and it should not be asked to do the rat feeder's job. RentACoop's 25-pound bucket has four large hooded ports, a diverter inside so feed keeps moving down, a lid, an anti-roost cone, and a stand. The page says the hoods reduce scattering, so more feed stays in the feeder and less ends up on the ground. That is the no-waste half of the title, and for a lot of flocks it is the only half that matters. The price was $69.95.
The rat half is a sliding cover on each port. RentACoop's instructions are plain: leave the covers open during the day, and close them at night. That works if you are there at dusk, which is the same moment an automatic door is supposed to save you from. If you already walk out to close the coop, closing four covers is a small extra. If you bought an automatic door so you would stop walking out, this feeder does not finish that plan. A treadle does.
Birds 12 weeks and older, the listing says. Chicks need a chick feeder, not a port they cannot reach or a treadle that can pinch. Put this bucket under a roof even with the hoods. Hoods shrug off a shower. They are not a reason to stand a plastic hopper in an open storm.
Pros
- Four hooded ports and an internal diverter. RentACoop says the hoods cut scattering.
- Each port has a sliding cover. The page tells you to leave them open by day and close them at night against unwanted guests.
- 25 pounds, so you are not refilling a tiny hopper. The stand, screws, and stakes are included. Price was $69.95.
- An anti-roost cone is in the box. Plastic and lighter to move than a 15-pound steel treadle.
Cons
- Night protection is a chore you do yourself. Forget the covers and it is an open buffet.
- Ports still let a hen pull feed out. They waste less than a pan. They do not waste nothing.
- It is not galvanized steel. If you wanted a feeder you can leave in the weather for years, the treadles are the sturdier body.
- Not for chicks under 12 weeks, per the listing.
Who it is not for
A rat problem you are hoping the feeder will solve by itself. The covers only work if you close them. It is also listed for birds 12 weeks and older, not for chicks.
- Capacity
- 25 lb
- Ports
- 4 large, with sliding covers and rain hoods
- Age
- 12 weeks and older, per RentACoop
- Included
- Bucket and lid, anti-roost cone, adjustable stand, screws, stakes
- Night mode
- You close the covers. They do not close themselves.
- Price
- $69.95 on the RentACoop page
Sources: RentACoop 25 lb 4-port feeder.
Pick the problem before you pick the feeder
- Hens rake feed out of a pan, and you do not see rodents: the four-port bucket. Close the covers at night anyway.
- You are feeding sparrows, or you find droppings that are not your hens' in the feed: a treadle. Grandpa's if you want the printed training plan. RentACoop if you want the rain cover and anti-roost lid in the box.
- Two or three birds and you want to spend fifty dollars to try ports: the Roamwild, after you have read the UK review about rats feeding from above.
- Chicks: none of these. Use a chick feeder until they are big enough for the one you bought. Grandpa's is explicit that chicks can get caught in the lid.
What a feeder will not do
A closed feeder does not make a coop rodent-proof. Rats eat eggs, they nest in bedding, and they clean up the scratch your hens fling while the lid is open. During Grandpa's two training weeks the lid is held open on purpose. That is the week to be the most careful about what else is on the ground, not the least. Several keepers in the training thread ended up talking about traps, not about a better hinge. The feeder is one tool.
Wild birds can get hurt in a treadle, too. In a step-on feeder thread, a keeper said sparrows would eat beside the hens and then get caught when the hens stepped off and the lid closed. That is grim, and it is a reason to watch the first weeks rather than a reason to pretend the category is gentle. If songbirds are thick around your run, a port feeder you close yourself may be the kinder tool.
What we left off
Open hanging pans, including the common galvanized Harris Farms pans, are cheap and they are not on this list. They do not stop a hen from billing feed out, and they do not close at night. Under a roof, with no rodents, a pan is a perfectly ordinary feeder. It is the wrong answer to the question in the title.
We also skipped treadle copies we could not tie to a stable spec page, and the Australian Dine-A-Chook feeders, because we did not confirm a straightforward US product page and price. A short list of feeders we could actually read is more useful than a tenth box with a guessed capacity.
Keeper threads we read
These are public conversations, not tests we ran. People disagree, and a single winter is not a verdict.
Questions people actually ask
Will a treadle feeder make the coop rat-proof?
No. It closes the feed when no bird is on the step. Rats still eat what hens spill, and they still want eggs and shelter. Grandpa's says the lid prevents rats and sparrows from reaching the feed. A city keeper on Reddit said large rats still got into theirs. Close the feed, then deal with spills, storage, and the rest of the coop.
How long does it take chickens to learn a treadle feeder?
Grandpa's ships a two-week plan: about a week fully open, then about a week half open, then closed. On r/BackYardChickens some flocks are faster and some take about a month. The week the lid starts to move is when birds get spooked and may stop eating. Have another way to feed them that week. Do not leave the lid propped open at night if rats are the reason you bought the feeder.
Are port feeders rat-resistant?
The RentACoop four-port feeder on this page is a waste feeder. The covers keep animals out only if you slide them shut. Roamwild says its spring ports are pest-proof without training. A review on Roamwild's own UK page says rats fed from the ledge above the port within a week. Read that before you buy the claim.
Can bantams or chicks use these?
Grandpa's says not to use the treadle with baby chicks, because a chick can be caught when a bigger bird steps off. Light bantams may need weight added to the treadle, which the maker describes. RentACoop's port feeder is listed for birds 12 weeks and older. Roamwild's ports assume a chicken heavy enough to open the spring.
Related on this site
Chicken feeders
Waste, rats, and why an open pan is a different purchase.
Cold-weather automatic doors
A treadle does not help if the pop-hole stays open all night.
Heated waterers for winter
Feed without water is a bad winter. The waterer page is the matching list.